The Celtics Steal the Show
Every
story has two sides, the old saying goes. But after digging into a tale I heard
from an old college friend, I've come to believe there are three sides to every
story: each participant's and the reporter's who tells it.
Here's
the story as recounted to me by my friend Charlie Hamilton, a well-known
character from the UT campus during my grad school days in the early seventies.
Charlie grew up in White Pine, Tennessee, and one summer he worked as a gopher
for the notable Morristown businessman Z Buda. While moving a file cabinet,
Charlie discovered an old newspaper article taped to the back. And that's where
this story comes from.
In
the 1940s, Z Buda owned a popular steakhouse in Newport and sponsored an
independent basketball team, Z Buda’s All Stars. They had a fierce rivalry with
another nearby independent team, the Cosby Hot Shots. After losing two straight
games to the Hot Shots, Z Buda was determined not to lose again.
After
both teams had warmed up for the third match,
they returned to their respective dressing rooms. But when the Z Buda All Stars
reappeared on the court, something was different. Now wearing the All Stars'
uniforms were five players from the Boston Celtics!
Charlie’s
story sounded so fantastic that I knew it had to be true, or at least mostly
true. And, as it turns out, it was!
It
took some digging through old newspaper clippings, but I finally unearthed this
February 29, 1948 column by Knoxville News-Sentinel sports editor Bob
Wilson:
Newport
Cage Team Pulls Big Surprise When Cosby Imports Former Vol Stars for Meet
Best
basketball yarn I've heard this season comes out of Cocke County... There was
an independent tournament going on at Cosby and the rivalry between the Cosby
Hot Shots and Z. Buda's Steak House team of Newport, was keen. The Cosby
manager, so the story goes, imported Bill Wright and Ted Cook, two former U-T
stars from Knoxville, to play on his team, which probably wasn't exactly
cricket, as the boys say... Well, came the night that Cosby's Hot Shots and
Buda's Steak House lads faced each other on the court in a crucial tournament
game the Hotshots, with Wright and Cook in their lineup, took the upper hand as
the firing started... However, after about five minutes of play the Buda team
called time out and all five players headed for the sideline, while five
towering hardwood performers, who had quietly come out of the locker-room,
rushed on the court
It
was the New York Celtics' starting quintet and when the Hot Shots took a look
at the professional stars, they tossed up the sponge and called it quits. Buda,
the restaurant proprietor and sponsor of the Steak House quint, being resentful
of Cosby importing Wright and Cook, had engaged the Celtics at a cost of $350
to come unannounced to the tournament and play for his team .. Their appearance
on the court was as much a surprise to the spectators as the Hot Shots for only
Buda and his players knew they were coming.
Holy
hoopsters! It was true.
One
detail was a little off. It was not the Boston Celtics but the New York
Celtics. The Boston Celtics were one of the eight teams that founded the NBA in
1946.
The
New York Celtics were even older, founded before World War I as a barnstorming team,
and considered one of the first professional basketball teams. But that group
had disbanded at the start of World War II and the Celtics that showed up in
the Newport gym that night in 1948 was new version created by former Original Celtics
player Dave Cullerton, who had been a three-sport star at Centre College. This group
had no relationship to the Boston Celtics.
Z
Buda didn’t fly them in for his All-Stars game either. They had played two
nights earlier against the Morristown VFW and the next night against the
Knoxville Globetrotters. For the Celtics five it was a short trip to Newport
and an easy payday.
But
the story doesn’t end there. A week later sports editor Wilson returned to his
typewriter for a follow up:
It
seems that there is another side to the recent Cocke County Independent
Basketball Tournament controversy which resulted in Z. Buda subsidizing the New
York Celtics to oppose the Cosby Hot Shots under the name of Buda's Steak
House. M. L. Cureton, manager of the Hot Shots, gives the Hot Shot's side of
the argument in the following communique, which was passed along to me by the
editor:
"In
your Sport Talk by Bob Wilson under date of Sunday, Feb. 29, it appears that
Mr. Wilson needs some information. This information could change his yarn which
he states is the best one he has heard this season to true facts.
"In
the first place he is misinformed as to place of play. This tournament was not
held at Cosby, but at Newport, the home town of Z. Buda's Steak House.
"It
is true that there is considerable rivalry between the Cosby Hot Shots, and Z.
Buda's Steak House. It is true that the Cosby manager imported Bill Wright and
Ted Cook, former U-T Vol players, to play with his team. It is also true that
he imported John Waddell of Greene County to play with the Hot Shots.
"Now:
It is also true that Z. Buda imported Gosnell, and Matthews from up Washington
College way, and Wolfenbarger from Rutledge to play with his team. Also Mr. Poteet
from Johnson City, so if it wasn't exactly cricket for the Hot Shots to get
outside players. it wasn't exactly cricket for Z. Buda to get outside players.
Both teams imported players so neither team was strictly Cocke County material.
"It
is also true that all of Cosby's Hot Shots played the first two games of the
tournament, and no new players were added for the final game. All players on
both teams were entered in this tournament before playing time, and the
bringing of the N. Y. Celtics into this tournament was a violation of rules,
and if Cosby had played this team, they would not have been playing Z. Buda, as
the New York Celtics are a team all their own.
"As
to the Hot Shots looking at the Celtics and tossing up the sponge and calling
it quits: Your Mr. Wilson would have been better qualified to write about this
game, if he had been a spectator.
"He
could have seen the Hot Shots out in front by a score of 10 to 5. He could have
seen Mr. Wade Clarke, who has played ball with the Steak House, in action as an
official. Mr. Clarke had two fouls on Sutton and one on Templin in around four
minutes of play. Sutton and Templin were Cosby players. He could have seen
between four and five hundred dissatisfied fans march by the box and receive
their $1 admission refunded. In this number was Mr. Alex Buda, father of Z.
Buda.
"All
bets on this game were cancelled and if Cosby had tossed in the sponge, the
manager of the Steak House team would have collected all bets.
"I
am writing this to let you know there are two versions of this affair."
Ah,
but there is a third version of this affair – the third side of the story - and
it arrived in the sports editor’s mailbox three days later, from, of course, Z
Buda himself.
The
Cosby Hot Shots-Buda's Steak House basketball controversy, which resulted from
a tournament game at Newport, still rages…Z. Buda, who sponsors the Steak House
boys, was more or less fuming over a letter written by Manager Cureton of the
Hot Shots, and published in this column Sunday....In order to settle the
squabble he offers to meet the Hot Shots in a game, both teams using their
regular players, with the proceeds going to Bill Wright, who played for the Hot
Shots, and who is now ill.
"We
will play Cosby any time, any place and spot them 10 points, regular team
against regular team," said Buda. "I suggest that we get two good
officials out-of-town for the game."
Buda
said he was just waiting for the Hot Shots to send in a letter of explanation
before he told his side of the story:
"They
said I imported players for the tournament, which is not true. Gosnell,
Matthews and Wolfenbarger have played for my team for two years," he
writes. "Wade Clark, a TSAA and Southern Conference official, officiated
when Cosby beat us 36-29 this year, and they picked him to call the tournament
along with Webb of Maryville. Cosby wanted me to co-sponsor the tournament with
them and we were to split the gate receipts. When I brought the Celtics on the
court they refused to play. I was the one who had the official announce a
refund of the money to the fans when Cosby didn't want to, for I'm not in
basketball for the money, but merely for the sport and sport alone. I might add
that Cosby officials told me to get anybody I wanted to for my team as they had
the best team there was. They thought I would go to Knoxville and get players
and they knew that all the good ones were in Atlanta playing in a tournament.
They thought I was sunk.
"Most
of the people in Cosby were pulling for my team, for we beat them 59-38 at
Cosby two weeks before the tournament. I would like to know where you got your
first story, especially about what I paid the Celtics. I got them here with the
help of Greeneville and Morristown, and not even close to the amount you said.
"Greeneville
barred Cosby from competing in their tournament for using Cook and Wright
against them.
"There
were no lists of players turned in for our tournament, however, it was agreed
that teams would use their regular players. I didn't get in touch with the
Celtics until Cosby had used Wright and Cook. I would not have used the Celtics
if Cosby had used their regular players."
There
you have it: the true story of the night the New York, not Boston, Celtics
played in Newport, Tennessee, masquerading as a local steak house quintet.
If you
are curious, here are the New York Celtics players as listed in the Knoxville
News-Sentinel story about their game against the Knoxville Globetrotters team:
Members
of the Celtics and their former colleges are: Tom Gatzek, Texas Christian; Bob
Karstens, Pittsburgh; Frank Horazy, NYU; Tony Crement, Illinois; Jack Jennings,
Tennessee; and Junior Kertesz, Manhattan College.
According
to the newspaper the Celtics claimed to have won 96 of 104 games at that point
in the season.
They
frequently toured with the Harlem Globetrotters, usually playing an undercard
game against either the Hawaiian All-Stars or Jesse Owens’ Kansas City
All-Stars.
Alex
“Z” Buda Jr. was a well-known Newport businessman. He got his nickname in high
school from his zig-zag style of running on the Newport High football team. After
serving in the Navy during World War II, he returned to Newport and opened his
namesake steak house. (He had learned the restaurant business from his father,
who had owned Newport’s popular Busy Bee Café.) Buda went on to own numerous businesses
in Cocke and Hamblen counties. He opened the first outlet mall in Pigeon Forge
and was instrumental in turning the town into a tourist mecca. His Z Buda’s
Smokies Campground is now The Island tourist attraction. At one time he owned
Minnis Drug Store in Morristown, where he had worked as a teenager. He was
credited with funding over 1,000 scholarships at Walters State community
college. He served three terms as mayor of Morristown.
His
Celtics shenanigan was just a footnote in a long career.